| Tahun | Pemenang dan nominee | Penyunting |
| 1996 | Independence Day | David Brenner |
| The English Patient | Walter Murch |
| Fargo | Roderick Jaynes |
| Mission: Impossible | Paul Hirsch |
| Romeo + Juliet | Jill Bilcock |
| 1997 | Titanic | Conrad Buff dan Richard A. Harris |
| Air Force One | Richard Francis-Bruce |
| Amistad | Michael Kahn |
| Boogie Nights | Dylan Tichenor |
| L.A. Confidential | Peter Honess |
| 1998 | Saving Private Ryan | Michael Kahn |
| Beloved | Carol Littleton |
| Pleasantville | William Goldenberg |
| Shakespeare in Love | David Gamble dan Christopher Greenbury |
| The Thin Red Line | Leslie Jones, Saar Klein, dan Billy Weber |
| 1999 | The Sixth Sense | Andrew Mondshein |
| American Beauty | Tariq Anwar dan Christopher Greenbury |
| Buena Vista Social Club | Monica Anderson dan Brian Johnson |
| The Insider | William Goldenberg, David Rosenbloom, dan Paul Rubell |
| Sleepy Hollow | Chris Lebenzon dan Joel Negron |
| The Talented Mr. Ripley | Walter Murch |
